India · Analysis

India vs New Zealand Tests 2026: What the 2020 Defeat and the 2024 Whitewash Reveal Before Wellington

India return to Wellington and Christchurch for two Tests. The 2020 and 2024 defeats to New Zealand look like opposites, but the scorecards show the same collapse.

Players in whites during a Test match at the Basin Reserve in Wellington, with a crowd on the bank and wooded hills behind

India return to the Basin Reserve on Thursday 19 November 2026 for the first of two Tests against New Zealand, with the second at Hagley Oval from 27 November. These are the grounds where India lost 2-0 on their last Test tour of New Zealand in 2020. The opponents are the side that beat them 3-0 in India in 2024.

The two defeats look like opposites. In 2020 New Zealand’s seamers took 38 of the 40 Indian wickets that fell, and their spinners none. In 2024 New Zealand’s spinners took 37 of 60. Yet the scorecards show the same failure in both series: in four of the five Tests, India had a foothold and lost it in a single collapse.

Two defeats that look like opposites

It is tempting to file 2020 under “India struggle with seam and swing” and 2024 under “India can’t play spin”. Both labels describe how the wickets fell. Neither explains why India lost from positions where they were level or ahead.

The more useful question for 2026 is not which type of bowling India will face. It is whether this team can stop one bad session from deciding a Test.

2020: four innings, no total above 242

TestIndiaNew ZealandResult
Wellington165 and 191348 and 9/0NZ won by 10 wickets
Christchurch242 and 124235 and 132/3NZ won by 7 wickets

India batted 258.1 overs in the series and made 722 runs, about 18 runs for every wicket. No Indian scored a hundred; the highest score was Mayank Agarwal’s 58 in Wellington. Tim Southee took 14 wickets, Trent Boult 11 and Kyle Jamieson nine. Ajaz Patel bowled six overs in the series and took none.

Christchurch is the more revealing defeat. India took a seven-run first-innings lead, then were bowled out for 124 in 46 overs, with Boult taking 4 for 28. New Zealand reached their target of 132 for the loss of three wickets.

The gap between the sides was widest after the fifth wicket. In their two first innings, New Zealand’s last five wickets added 141 and 102 runs, with Jamieson making 44 and 49. India’s last five wickets added 64, 43, 48 and 40 in their four innings.

2024: three Tests, three different collapses

TestIndiaNew ZealandResult
Bengaluru46 and 462402 and 110/2NZ won by 8 wickets
Pune156 and 245259 and 255NZ won by 113 runs
Mumbai263 and 121235 and 174NZ won by 25 runs

In Bengaluru, India were bowled out for 46 in 31.2 overs, and every wicket went to a seamer: Matt Henry took 5 for 15 and William O’Rourke 4 for 22. The second innings recovered to 408 for 3. India then lost their last seven wickets for 54.

In Pune, Mitchell Santner came into the side and took 7 for 53 and 6 for 104. India were 50 for 1 in their first innings and were all out for 156.

In Mumbai, India led by 28 on first innings and needed 147 to win. They were 29 for 5 after 7.1 overs and lost by 25 runs. Ajaz took 5 for 103 and 6 for 57, match figures of 11 for 160.

The thread that links both series

Look past the bowling type and the same pattern appears four times:

  • Christchurch 2020: first-innings lead of seven, then 124 all out.
  • Bengaluru 2024: 408 for 3, then 462 all out.
  • Pune 2024: 50 for 1, then 156 all out.
  • Mumbai 2024: first-innings lead of 28, then 121 all out chasing 147.

Only Wellington 2020 was a defeat in which India never had a foothold. Five Tests is a small sample, and pitch, toss and opposition quality all played a part. But the evidence points to a team that lost control once two or three wickets fell quickly, regardless of who was bowling.

Ajaz himself named another factor. Speaking after the 2024 series, he called the toss “so important” in the subcontinent. That is a fair caveat for Pune and Mumbai, where New Zealand batted first. It matters less in New Zealand, where the first session usually belongs to the bowlers.

How New Zealand changed their attack

New Zealand did not win either series with one method. In 2020 their spinners took no wickets. In 2024 Santner played only in Pune and Ish Sodhi only in Mumbai, picked for the surface in front of them.

After the 2024 series, Ajaz said New Zealand had “prepared on turning wickets” at home and practised on different surfaces before the tour. In his words, the series was “three different surfaces and three different games”.

India should expect the same flexibility in reverse. New Zealand had not named their Test squad at the time of writing, so the balance of their attack, and whether a specialist spinner plays at home at all, is still open.

A different India squad

India’s 16-man squad has little direct memory of 2020. Only three players, Jasprit Bumrah, Rishabh Pant and Ravindra Jadeja, played in India’s Tests in New Zealand that year. Jadeja played the second Test only.

RolePlayers
BattersShubman Gill (captain), Yashasvi Jaiswal, KL Rahul (vice-captain), Devdutt Padikkal, Sai Sudharsan
WicketkeepersRishabh Pant (subject to fitness clearance), Dhruv Jurel
All-roundersRavindra Jadeja, Washington Sundar, Nitish Kumar Reddy
SpinnerKuldeep Yadav
Fast bowlersJasprit Bumrah, Mohammed Siraj, Akash Deep, Prasidh Krishna, Anshul Kamboj

The top order’s best evidence away from home comes from England in 2025. Gill made 754 runs in 10 innings as captain, and Rahul made 532 as an opener in a series India drew 2-2. That was one series in different conditions, but it is the strongest sign that this group can bat through long spells of seam.

Against New Zealand specifically, the record is thinner. Gill made 144 runs in four innings in 2024. Jaiswal made 190 in six, with 77 at Pune his best. Neither Gill, Jaiswal nor Rahul played in India’s 2020 Tests in New Zealand. Pant was India’s top scorer in 2024 with 261 runs, but made 60 in four innings in New Zealand in 2020.

Pant’s place is also uncertain. His selection is subject to fitness clearance after a side strain, and he was reported on 2 November not to have cleared his first fitness test. Jurel is the alternative wicketkeeper.

Bumrah and the pace attack

Bumrah returns after missing India’s Tests against Sri Lanka. He has 234 wickets in 52 Tests at an average of 19.79 and an economy rate, the runs conceded per over, of 2.77. His only Test tour of New Zealand was less productive: six wickets in two Tests at 31.50.

The depth around him has changed. Mohammed Siraj took 23 wickets in England in 2025. Akash Deep is back after a stress fracture. Prasidh Krishna missed the ODIs with a hamstring injury, and the selectors plan for him to play an India A match first, subject to a return-to-play assessment. Mohammed Shami was not selected.

The lower-order lesson from 2020 also applies here. In our reading, Washington Sundar, Nitish Kumar Reddy and Jadeja are India’s best answer to the lower-order gap of 2020. Whether two of them can play alongside four seamers is the main selection question.

What the grounds have done since

Recent Tests suggest the two venues will not behave identically. At the Basin Reserve in December 2025, New Zealand beat West Indies by nine wickets, bowling them out for 205 and 128. At Hagley Oval the same month, West Indies batted 163.3 overs in the fourth innings to save the match at 457 for 6.

That is one Test per ground, so it proves little on its own. It does warn against assuming two seaming pitches and picking the same attack for both.

What to watch in Wellington and Christchurch

  • The first session at the Basin Reserve: in 2020 India were 40 for 3 inside 18 overs in Wellington.
  • Overs after the fifth wicket: whether India’s lower order can add the 100-plus that New Zealand’s did.
  • New Zealand’s selection: whether they pick a spinner at home, and who leads the seam attack.
  • Pant’s fitness: it decides India’s batting depth at six and who keeps wicket.

India have changed most of the side that lost in 2020 and much of the one that lost in 2024. The scorecards suggest the real test is not seam or spin. It is whether a new group can hold on to a winning position once they have one.

Tell us

Join the conversation