My view is simple: Marnus Labuschagne should not play the first Test against New Zealand in Perth on 9 December, but nobody should treat that as the end of his Test career. Coach Andrew McDonald has not made that call, and on the evidence, neither should anyone else.
The case for leaving him out is strong. Labuschagne made 131 runs at 21.83 in six innings in South Africa, with a highest score of 39. He has now gone 49 Test innings without a century, and his last 10 Test innings have produced 204 runs at 20.40, without a fifty.
McDonald was frank after the series. He said the selectors would “reassess” their belief in Labuschagne and that “he hasn’t taken his opportunity on this tour”. He also said: “There’s still a very good cricketer there. Every time he drops back to state level, he outperforms the others.” Both halves of that verdict matter.
The South Africa series, innings by innings
| Test | Score | How the innings ended |
|---|---|---|
| 1st, Durban | 37 | Beaten by a Wiaan Mulder delivery that nipped back; his review was unsuccessful |
| 1st, Durban | 37 | Edged Keshav Maharaj and was caught by Temba Bavuma |
| 2nd, Gqeberha | 14 | Caught off Anrich Nortje as Australia were bowled out for 99 |
| 2nd, Gqeberha | 39 | Survived an lbw review by 4.7 millimetres, then was caught at deep mid-on trying to hit Simon Harmer into a strong wind, with Australia following on |
| 3rd, Cape Town | 0 | Caught at slip off Harmer after an uncertain start |
| 3rd, Cape Town | 4 | Lbw to Kagiso Rabada early on the final day as Australia were bowled out for 111 chasing 288 |
Starts that do not become scores
The first pattern is conversion. Labuschagne made between 37 and 39 in three of his six innings, and before Cape Town, six of his previous nine Test scores fell between 30 and 49. McDonald described that range as a danger period for him. I agree, and I think it is the clearest sign of where his batting is right now. He is still doing the hard part, surviving the new ball and getting in, and then giving his wicket away before the innings can shape the match.
The second pattern is spin. Three of his six dismissals came against spinners: Maharaj once and Harmer twice. The dismissal in Gqeberha hurt most. Australia were batting to save the Test, he had already survived a tight lbw review, and he chose to attack Harmer into the wind. In Cape Town, Harmer had him caught at slip without scoring. Those are not the dismissals of a batter who has lost his technique overnight. To me they look like a batter whose decision-making has been squeezed by pressure.
That distinction matters for what comes next. A technical flaw may need a long rebuild. Poor decisions under pressure are often best fixed away from Test cricket, where runs come more freely and the stakes are lower.
The longer slide
The South Africa tour was not a one-off. Labuschagne averaged 60.82 across his first 30 Tests and had 10 Test centuries from his first 51 innings by December 2022. In the 71 innings since, he has made one century. His career average now stands at 42.64 across 68 Tests, still a respectable figure, but one that has fallen steadily for almost four years.
The selectors have been patient. They kept him for the South Africa tour after he made 1, 31 and 4 against Bangladesh in August. That patience has now run its course for this series, but I do not think it should run out altogether.
Who could bat at No.3?
| Option | Test record | Recent form | My view |
|---|---|---|---|
| Josh Inglis | Made 102 in Cape Town, the same score he made on Test debut in Galle in 2025 | Century in the series decider | Has earned a place, but I would keep him in the middle order |
| Steve Smith | Australia’s most experienced batter, aged 37 | Missed Cape Town with a neck injury; expected back for New Zealand | A short-term option at best |
| Sam Konstas | 5 Tests, 163 runs at 16.30 | 71 and 151 not out for NSW against Western Australia in October | Clear talent, but his Test record argues for patience |
| Kurtis Patterson | 2 Tests in 2019, 144 runs, dismissed once, top score 114 not out | A Shield century against Western Australia in October, his 16th first-class hundred | The best specialist No.3 option on current form |
No option is perfect, which is part of why Labuschagne lasted the tour. My preference is a specialist No.3 rather than another reshuffle. Inglis made his runs in the middle order in Cape Town, and moving him up would solve one problem by creating another. Patterson is 33, so he is not a long-term answer, but he is in form in red-ball cricket and has already made a Test century. For a four-Test series against New Zealand, that is enough.
Can domestic cricket bring him back?
Labuschagne has done this before. He was dropped from the Test side in June 2025, went back to Queensland, and made 160 and 159 in his first two Sheffield Shield matches of the following season. That was enough to return him to the Test team for the Ashes.
Queensland play Tasmania at the Gabba from 11 November. If Labuschagne plays and makes big runs, he becomes the natural reserve batter for the New Zealand series. With four Tests packed inside 31 days, and a tour of India to follow, Australia are likely to need one.
My verdict
Leave Labuschagne out for Perth, and say clearly why: the starts are not becoming scores, and his decisions against spin have let him down. Then make the way back just as clear. He is 32, his career average is still above 42, and the last time he was dropped, he answered with two Shield centuries.
His Test career is at a crossroads, not a dead end. What he does for Queensland in the next five weeks should decide which road he takes.
Join the conversation
0 comments